Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy warned Saturday that proposed security guarantees modeled on NATO’s collective defense commitments remain insufficiently defined, demanding written assurances capable of protecting Ukraine against renewed Russian aggression for decades rather than only during President Donald Trump’s remaining time in office. Speaking to journalists following a major diplomatic gathering in Berlin, Zelenskyy said Ukraine had yet to receive concrete documentation explaining how the proposed protections would operate, which countries would participate and whether those governments would be prepared to respond militarily to another Russian attack. He reiterated that full NATO membership remains Kyiv’s preferred security arrangement, arguing that the alliance’s existing collective defense framework offers greater certainty than alternative agreements still under negotiation. The remarks come as Washington and European governments examine possible arrangements to guarantee Ukraine’s long-term security as part of efforts to end Russia’s war. Zelenskyy cautioned that an agreement providing only temporary protection could allow Moscow to resume military operations once those commitments expire.

The president’s concerns center on proposals for security guarantees resembling Article 5 of the North Atlantic Treaty, the provision establishing NATO’s collective defense principle. Under Article 5, an armed attack against one NATO member is treated as an attack against all, requiring allies to provide assistance through measures they consider necessary, potentially including military force. Although the provision does not automatically require every member to deploy troops, it creates a collective commitment supported by established alliance institutions, defense planning and military coordination. Zelenskyy said the proposed arrangement for Ukraine lacks comparable clarity, particularly regarding which governments would collectively respond to another Russian invasion and what their response would involve. He argued that describing a security framework as similar to Article 5 is insufficient without defining its obligations and enforcement mechanisms. The Ukrainian leader emphasized that promises of assistance must be translated into concrete written commitments rather than left dependent on political statements.

Zelenskyy also questioned whether security guarantees tied to the current U.S. administration would provide meaningful protection after Trump’s presidency ends. He said Ukraine needs commitments that remain credible for decades, regardless of future changes in American or European leadership. Referring to Trump’s recent characterization of Russian President Vladimir Putin as a friend, Zelenskyy warned that even a period of reduced Russian aggression would provide little lasting security if Moscow resumed military operations after the current administration leaves office. He described such an arrangement as a temporary interruption of hostilities rather than a sustainable settlement, warning that Ukraine could be forced to rebuild the international coalition supporting its defense if another invasion occurred. “That’s not a strong peace. That’s a two-year pause,” Zelenskyy said. His comments reflect concerns that a ceasefire without durable security arrangements could leave Ukraine vulnerable to another major military confrontation.

The debate intensified following the November 19 Coalition of the Willing summit in Berlin, which brought together more than 40 participants in person and remotely to coordinate military assistance, diplomatic negotiations and possible postwar security arrangements for Ukraine. The meeting was hosted by German Chancellor Friedrich Merz and attended by Zelenskyy, French President Emmanuel Macron, British Prime Minister Andy Burnham and senior representatives from European governments and international institutions. U.S. presidential envoys Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner also participated, reflecting Washington’s continuing role in negotiations involving Ukraine, Russia and European allies. The summit addressed additional air defense assistance, financial and military support, European participation in peace negotiations and measures intended to deter another Russian invasion after a ceasefire. Participating governments reaffirmed their support for Ukraine’s sovereignty and emphasized that European countries must be involved in decisions affecting the continent’s security. The gathering concluded with a joint statement outlining potential elements of a future security framework, although the arrangements have not yet been finalized.

During the Berlin discussions, Kushner said the Trump administration was open to providing Ukraine with security guarantees based on the principles of NATO’s Article 5, describing the possibility as part of a broader negotiated settlement. He also suggested that American negotiators had made progress toward securing Russian acceptance of the concept. However, Moscow subsequently rejected suggestions that Ukraine could receive an arrangement resembling membership in the Western military alliance, highlighting the uncertainty surrounding the proposed framework. Russian Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov described any form of Ukrainian quasi-membership in NATO as unacceptable, while Russian officials continued opposing the deployment of foreign military forces on Ukrainian territory. Trump separately declined to define the guarantees in detail before the conclusion of a broader peace agreement. The conflicting statements underscore the distance between preliminary diplomatic proposals and a mutually accepted security settlement.

A joint declaration issued following the Berlin meeting outlined several possible components of future security commitments, including sustained military and financial assistance, a U.S.-led ceasefire monitoring mechanism and a European-led multinational force intended to support stability following an agreement. The proposed multinational force could contribute to security arrangements in Ukrainian airspace, at sea and on land while assisting with the reconstruction and development of the country’s armed forces. The declaration also raised the possibility of legally binding commitments requiring participating governments to respond if Russia launched another attack, subject to their respective national procedures. Those proposals provide a general framework for further negotiations but do not constitute a completed agreement defining the precise obligations of each participating country. Zelenskyy’s latest remarks indicate that Kyiv is seeking more detailed guarantees specifying how the collective response would function in practice. Questions surrounding military deployments, response mechanisms, legal commitments and implementation remain unresolved.

The Ukrainian president also argued that NATO membership could ultimately provide a more effective and economical long-term defense arrangement than building a completely independent military capable of deterring Russia without alliance protection. Zelenskyy said Ukraine might otherwise need to maintain a force of approximately one million personnel, supported by sufficient combat aircraft, artillery, missile systems and air defense capabilities to protect the country independently. Such a force would require sustained investment in personnel, equipment, training and military infrastructure over many years. He suggested that integrating Ukraine into NATO would distribute elements of the security burden across the alliance while allowing Ukraine’s combat experience and military capabilities to strengthen collective defense. The president acknowledged, however, that membership remains uncertain and depends partly on the outcome of the war and the willingness of existing allies to approve accession. NATO membership requires agreement among the alliance’s member governments, and no consensus has been reached on formally admitting Ukraine.

The discussions also reflect wider disagreements over the future European security architecture and the conditions under which negotiations with Russia should proceed. European governments have repeatedly argued that Ukraine must participate directly in decisions affecting its territory and future security, particularly as American diplomatic efforts continue involving Moscow. The Berlin coalition reaffirmed support for a settlement preserving Ukrainian sovereignty and establishing measures to discourage renewed hostilities, while also maintaining pressure on Russia through military assistance and sanctions. Officials have emphasized the importance of strengthening Ukraine’s air defenses and protecting critical infrastructure as Russian missile and drone attacks continue. Zelenskyy has supported continued diplomatic engagement but maintains that any peace agreement must provide more than a temporary reduction in fighting. His government is also seeking closer integration with the European Union as an additional foundation for long-term political, economic and security cooperation.

The central challenge remains determining whether the United States, European governments and Ukraine can agree on enforceable security commitments capable of surviving future political transitions. Any agreement would need to address the responsibilities of participating governments, the conditions triggering assistance and the mechanisms available to respond to renewed Russian aggression. It would also require clarity about military support, possible international deployments and the relationship between Ukraine’s future defense arrangements and NATO’s existing obligations. For Zelenskyy, the distinction between an informal political assurance and a binding collective defense commitment is essential to preventing another war. Although the Berlin summit demonstrated continued diplomatic coordination among Ukraine’s allies, the details of the proposed NATO-style guarantees remain unsettled. Kyiv continues to insist that lasting peace will depend not merely on ending the current fighting, but on establishing security arrangements strong enough to prevent it from beginning again.